facebook twitter instagram linkedin google youtube vimeo tumblr yelp rss email podcast phone blog search brokercheck brokercheck Play Pause
Pro Rata, Not "Double Tax" Thumbnail

Pro Rata, Not "Double Tax"

The IRA pro-rata rule can create confusion for people who hold both pre-tax and after-tax retirement funds. When you make a Roth conversion or withdraw money from an IRA that contains both types of funds, the IRS requires you to account for the proportion of each. You cannot simply withdraw or convert only your after-tax contributions to avoid taxes.

This rule often surprises people who have made nondeductible IRA contributions or rolled after-tax funds into an IRA. Some assume that converting those dollars will trigger double taxation because they already paid taxes on the original contributions. However, the pro-rata rule does not tax the same dollars twice. It determines how much of each distribution or conversion represents taxable and nontaxable funds.

What Is the IRA Pro-Rata Rule?

The IRA pro-rata rule determines how much of an IRA withdrawal or Roth conversion is taxable when an individual holds both pre-tax and after-tax retirement funds.

The IRS looks at the total balance across an individual's traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs and SIMPLE IRAs. For tax purposes, these accounts are treated as one combined pool of money. The proportion of after-tax funds compared with the total balance determines how much of a distribution or conversion escapes taxation.

For example, if 10% of your combined IRA balance consists of after-tax funds, then 10% of a distribution or Roth conversion generally represents nontaxable money. The remaining 90% represents taxable funds.

You cannot separate after-tax contributions into a different IRA at another financial institution to avoid this calculation. The IRS considers the applicable IRA accounts together.

Which Retirement Accounts Count Toward the Pro-Rata Rule?

The pro-rata calculation includes the following accounts:

  • Traditional IRAs
  • SEP IRAs
  • SIMPLE IRAs

The IRS treats these accounts as one combined pool when calculating the taxable portion of an IRA distribution or Roth conversion.

However, certain retirement accounts do not factor into the calculation. Inherited IRAs, Roth IRAs and employer-sponsored retirement plans, such as 401(k)s, are excluded from the pro-rata calculation described here.

Understanding which accounts count is important before attempting a Roth conversion. Even if you plan to convert funds from just one traditional IRA, the balances in your other applicable IRA accounts can affect the tax consequences.

How Does the IRA Pro-Rata Rule Work?

Consider Ralph, who owns a traditional IRA worth $100,000. He does not have any other traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs or SIMPLE IRAs.

Within his $100,000 account, Ralph has $10,000 in after-tax, nondeductible funds. The remaining $90,000 consists of pre-tax funds. The source of the after-tax money does not matter for this example. It could come from previous nondeductible contributions or an after-tax rollover from an employer plan.

Ralph wants to convert $10,000 from his traditional IRA into a Roth IRA.

His account contains a 90% pre-tax and 10% after-tax balance. Under the pro-rata rule, 90% of his Roth conversion will be taxable, while 10% will represent nontaxable funds.

That means Ralph's $10,000 conversion breaks down as follows:

  • $9,000: Taxable pre-tax funds.
  • $1,000: Nontaxable after-tax funds.

Ralph cannot select only the $10,000 of after-tax money for conversion. The IRS requires him to convert a proportional share of each type of fund.

Why the Pro-Rata Rule Does Not Create Double Taxation

Ralph initially believes the IRS is taxing him twice. He already paid taxes on his $10,000 of after-tax IRA funds, so he does not understand why part of his Roth conversion is taxable.

However, the calculation does not tax his original after-tax contributions again. Instead, it separates the taxable and nontaxable portions of the conversion. After Ralph converts $10,000, his Roth IRA contains $10,000 in funds. That amount consists of $9,000 in previously untaxed money and $1,000 in after-tax money.

His traditional IRA balance falls to $90,000. The remaining funds consist of:

  • $81,000: Pre-tax funds.
  • $9,000: After-tax funds.

The ratio remains 90% pre-tax and 10% after-tax.

When Ralph combines his traditional and Roth IRA balances, he still has $100,000 in retirement assets. However, his after-tax funds now total $19,000: $1,000 in the Roth IRA and $9,000 in the traditional IRA, along with the original $9,000 of after-tax funds that remain there.

The original $10,000 of after-tax money was not taxed twice. The conversion simply transferred a proportional amount of pre-tax and after-tax funds into the Roth IRA.

What Should You Know Before a Roth Conversion?

The pro-rata rule can significantly affect the tax consequences of a Roth conversion, particularly for people who have made nondeductible IRA contributions or hold multiple IRA accounts.

Before converting funds, review the balances across all your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs. The amount you plan to convert does not determine the taxable percentage on its own. Your overall pre-tax and after-tax balance matters.

Understanding the pro-rata calculation can help you avoid unexpected tax bills and make more informed decisions about Roth conversions.

IRA Pro-Rata Rule: FAQ

What is the IRA pro-rata rule?

The IRA pro-rata rule determines how much of an IRA withdrawal or Roth conversion represents taxable pre-tax funds and nontaxable after-tax funds. The IRS calculates the proportions using the combined balances of applicable IRA accounts.

Which accounts count toward the IRA pro-rata rule?

Traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs and SIMPLE IRAs count toward the calculation. Inherited IRAs, Roth IRAs and employer-sponsored plans such as 401(k)s do not factor into the calculation described in the article.

Can I convert only my nondeductible IRA contributions to a Roth IRA?

No. If your applicable IRA accounts contain both pre-tax and after-tax funds, the pro-rata rule requires a proportional allocation of each type of money.

Does the pro-rata rule cause double taxation?

No. The rule does not tax the same after-tax dollars twice. It requires each distribution or conversion to include a proportional share of pre-tax and after-tax funds.

Does having multiple traditional IRAs change the pro-rata calculation?

Yes. The IRS considers your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances together rather than treating each account separately.

Does the pro-rata rule apply to Roth IRAs?

No. Roth IRAs are excluded from the pro-rata calculation for traditional IRA distributions and conversions.

How does the pro-rata rule affect a partial Roth conversion?

A partial Roth conversion must include a proportional share of pre-tax and after-tax funds. The taxable percentage depends on the overall balance across applicable IRA accounts, not simply the amount converted.

Can I avoid the pro-rata rule by opening another traditional IRA?

No. Opening a separate traditional IRA at another custodian does not shield after-tax funds from the calculation. The IRS considers applicable IRA accounts together.

Understanding the Pro-Rata Rule Before Converting

The IRA pro-rata rule can make Roth conversions more complicated when your retirement accounts contain a mixture of pre-tax and after-tax funds. However, it does not mean you will pay taxes twice on money you already taxed.

Understanding how the IRS calculates the taxable portion of a conversion can help you plan ahead, evaluate your retirement accounts and avoid surprises when tax season arrives. Before completing a Roth conversion, consider reviewing your entire IRA balance and the potential tax consequences with a qualified financial or tax professional.


Plan With Confidence

Secure your financial future with expert guidance. Schedule a complimentary consultation with a licensed advisor today.


Christian Cordoba, founder of California Retirement Advisors, has been a member of Ed Slott's Master Elite IRA Advisor Group since 2007.

Source: Andy Ives, CFP®, AIF®
IRA Analyst
Ed Slott and Company, LLC
Copyright © 2025, Ed Slott and Company, LLC Reprinted from The Slott Report, 06/30/25, with permission.https://irahelp.com/slottreport/pro-rata-not-double-tax/, Ed Slott and Company, LLC takes no responsibility for the current accuracy of this article. 
Investment advisory services offered through Mutual Advisors, LLC DBA California Retirement Advisors, a SEC registered investment advisor. Securities offered through Mutual Securities, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC. Mutual Securities, Inc. and Mutual Advisors, LLC are affiliated companies. CA Insurance license #0B09076. This content is developed from sources believed to be providing accurate information and provided by California Retirement Advisors. It may not be used for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties. Please consult legal or tax professionals for specific information regarding your individual situation. The opinions expressed and material provided are for general information and should not be considered a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security. California Retirement Advisors, nor any of its members, are tax accountants or legal attorneys and do not provide tax or legal advice. For tax or legal advice, you should consult your tax or legal professional.
The information being provided is strictly as a courtesy. When you click on any of the links provided here, you are leaving this website and viewing information provided by a third party. We make no representation as to the completeness or accuracy of information provided by any third-party website. Nor is the company liable for any direct or indirect technical or system issues or any consequences arising out of your access to, or your use of third-party technologies, websites, information and programs made available through this website. By accessing these calculators, you assume total responsibility and risk for your use of the third-party website.